American restaurants

Windamere

4.1 191 reviews 11:30 AM - 09:30 PM 2255 Wickham Ave, Mattituck, NY 11952, United States

Discover this place

Windamere, located at 2255 Wickham Ave in Mattituck, NY, promises a delightful culinary experience that combines delicious cuisine with scenic waterfront views. Customers rave about the exquisite food and attentive service, often highlighting their favorites, such as the Windamere burger—a rich, smoky delight—and various seafood dishes, including fried calamari and Prince Edward Island mussels.

The atmosphere is lively, thanks in part to the live music that often graces the establishment, enriching the dining experience. Visitors like James Wood describe dining outdoors as a beautiful escape, where the stunning views of water and boats enhance the overall ambiance. Attention to detail is evident, not just in the food, but also in the impeccable landscaping surrounding the restaurant.

Service at Windamere stands out, with staff members such as Page and Sandra receiving high praise for their warmth and attentiveness. Many customers express their intention to return, underlining Windamere’s charm as not just a restaurant but a place that feels like a getaway. Whether you are looking for a casual meal with friends or a romantic evening out, Windamere seems to cater to all, offering an experience worth savoring.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Fireplace
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great dessert
Great wine list
Live music
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Romantic
Trendy

Crowd

Family-friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safespace

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Windamere before visiting.

Reviews for Windamere

4.1

191 reviews

100%

24%

13%

14%

Review highlights

Based on 191 reviews

Windamere, an American restaurant located in Mattituck, consistently receives praise for its inviting waterfront atmosphere and well-maintained grounds, often highlighted by beautiful views and serene surroundings. Guests frequently commend the attentive and personable service, noting that staff members contribute significantly to the welcoming and enjoyable dining experience. The food quality is commonly described as delicious and carefully prepared, with standout mentions of seafood dishes and signature cocktails. Many reviewers appreciate the lively ambiance enhanced by live music and outdoor seating, which complements both casual and special-occasion visits. Overall, Windamere is recognized for blending picturesque scenery with flavorful cuisine and hospitable service, creating a memorable experience that encourages return visits.

Bob Dill

Jun 25, 2025

We made a quick choice to stop at the Windamere. Food was amazing and the Service was even better. The Windy Paloma was an awesome drink. Highly recommend. Page was our waitress and she was the Best!!!

James Wood

May 31, 2025

My wife and I recently dined at Windamere inside Strongs Water Club & Marina and had a delightful experience. The live band added a lively atmosphere, and sitting outside gave us beautiful views of the water and boats. We enjoyed delicious fried calamari, baked clams, and Prince Edward Island mussels. The grounds were immaculate and beautifully maintained, with a large pool and outdoor bar nearby. The lawn games like cornhole added to the vibrant vibe. Overall, it was an excellent experience with great food, stunning views, and a lively ambiance. Highly recommended!

Alexandra Small

May 05, 2025

We had a wonderful experience at Windamere in Mattituck. Our waitress, Sandra, was attentive, personable, and kind—she made us feel truly welcome. The food was delicious from start to finish, with each course arriving quickly and perfectly prepared. The beautiful waterfront scenery added to the relaxing atmosphere, and as locals, we felt like we were on vacation. We’ll definitely be back!

Tina H

May 04, 2025

This restaurant is on the same property as Strongs Marina. The landscaping is beautiful. The water view is serene. It was a Friday night and there was live music. We ate outside. The weather was perfect. The staff was attentive. The cocktails were delicious. The food was yummy. I will go again!

Ivan Mouzykin

Apr 22, 2025

The food was pretty good, especially the windamere burger — smoky, rich and juicy Sandwich with Cod was delicious, but cheese doesn’t belong there. Special thanks to Yaya for being super friendly and hospitable

Brenda Canales

Apr 11, 2025

Place is absolutely beautiful. We were a large party and the staff accommodated our needs. Food was absolutely delicious and I highly recommend the expresso martini!

Sondra Faivre

Apr 09, 2025

We revisited the location where our family hosted our 50th anniversary party nine years ago. It is under new ownership, and we went for an early dinner where we were, at one point, the only diners. We received excellent service from our server, Sandra F. She was very accommodating and pleasant. The food was outstanding, and we enjoyed the location and the views of the water. We will definitely return again.

Talya Djemil '26

Mar 11, 2025

Best restaurant out east. A definite must visit. All staff are so accommodating whether you are in a small party or a large private event. Food is great and specials are out of this world. I would recommend to friends and family.